Preparing for a cyber insurance renewal
Gather evidence for your cyber insurance renewal, describe control gaps accurately and ask your broker to clarify questions before you sign.

A cyber insurance renewal asks you to describe your business and the controls it has in place. The person signing may need evidence from IT, finance, operations and service providers to answer accurately.
Start with the application your broker has supplied. Forms, definitions and coverage differ. Don’t copy last year’s answers until you’ve checked what changed in the business, the systems and the questions. What a cyber insurance questionnaire is asking explains the groups of controls most forms cover.
Agree who will verify each answer
Name a business owner for the application and assign technical questions to someone who can inspect the configuration. IT can confirm how a control is implemented; your broker can clarify what the insurer’s wording requires.
Keep a working record for each question:
- the systems and people it covers;
- the current configuration and date checked;
- evidence supporting the answer;
- known gaps, exceptions and planned work;
- the person who verified it.
If a yes-or-no question doesn’t fit a partial rollout, ask your broker how to disclose that situation and get the answer in writing. A product licence or a planned deployment doesn’t mean the control is running yet.
Check coverage across the whole environment
For MFA, distinguish registration from enforcement and record which services and account types are protected. Include remote access and administrators. Some non-human accounts use other protections; ask how to describe them instead of treating every account as an employee login.
For endpoint security, compare the device inventory with the deployment report. Note unsupported devices, missing agents and who investigates alerts. If the form asks about continuous monitoring, check the hours the service covers and who is responsible for responding.
For backups, list the workloads covered, retention, protected copies and last successful restore tests. If immutability is requested, verify the enabled settings and their scope. Don’t infer it from a vendor name.
The Cyber Centre’s baseline controls provide a Canadian starting point for reviewing access, patching, backups, training and incident planning. Your insurer’s definitions still apply, and you’ll need your own evidence that your systems meet them.
Include the business processes
Have finance describe how payment instructions and bank-detail changes are verified. Record the real process, including exceptions, approval roles and how staff use a previously verified contact route.
For important suppliers, identify the data and access they hold, the service you depend on and the evidence you’ve received about their controls. A security report still needs to be read for its scope and period.
Check the incident plan’s contacts and whether a discussion exercise or recovery test has taken place. Give the date and outcome if asked. Having a plan on file doesn’t mean it’s been tested.
Separate current controls from planned changes
Describe gaps clearly, with an owner and a proposed date for the work. If a change will be finished before submission, verify it again and update the evidence. Don’t describe a quote, order or rollout plan as complete.
Ask your broker how incomplete controls affect the offer and whether changes must be reported during the policy term. The effect of an inaccurate answer depends on the application, policy and applicable law. Get advice on your specific wording; don’t assume either acceptance or a predictable premium.
Review the coverage as well as the questions
The Insurance Bureau of Canada’s coverage overview describes cyber policies, endorsements and the limitations of relying on traditional business coverage. Ask your broker to explain what your proposed policy covers and excludes.
Discuss limits, deductibles, business interruption, fraud and supplier incidents. Check notification deadlines, the incident contact number and whether the insurer must approve responders or expenses. Record those answers in the response plan.
Keep the signed application, supporting evidence, written clarifications and policy together in a controlled location. Assign someone to update the control record when systems or service agreements change.


