Colour theme
Book a consultation

What a cyber insurance questionnaire is asking

The questions insurers ask about your security controls, why they ask them, and how to answer accurately when some of the answers are no.

Person filling out an insurance form on a clipboard beside a laptop.

Most insurers send a questionnaire with the renewal: a few dozen yes-or-no questions about your security controls, with a signature at the bottom. It often lands with the office manager or the owner, who may not know all the answers.

The insurer relies on each answer when it prices the policy, and again if you make a claim. If a yes turns out to be wrong, it can give the insurer grounds to dispute the claim. A no with a note explaining what’s being done about it doesn’t.

Why they ask what they ask

The questions cover the controls that would have prevented the claims insurers have paid out on. The wording varies between forms, but the same groups come up:

  • Multi-factor authentication. On email, on remote access and on administrator accounts, often asked as three separate questions.
  • Backups. Whether a copy is kept separate from your network, whether it can be changed or deleted by an account on that network, and when you last restored from it.
  • Patching. How quickly critical updates go on, and whether anything is running software that no longer gets updates.
  • Endpoint protection. Whether you have endpoint detection and response, not only antivirus, and whether anyone watches the alerts.
  • Administrator access. Who has it, and whether admins use a separate account for admin work.
  • Email and training. Filtering on incoming mail, awareness training, and often phishing simulations.
  • An incident response plan. Whether it’s written down, and who you’d call.

Answer for today

Each question is about how things stand now. If multi-factor authentication is on for everyone except two accounts, the answer to “is it enforced for all users?” is no. Say which two, why, and when they’ll be fixed. Most forms have room for a note. The underwriter can work with an exact answer and an explanation.

Unsupported systems are a common example. A computer on an old version of Windows because a piece of equipment needs it isn’t automatically a problem. If it’s on its own network segment with no Internet access, say so, and say how it’s separated.

Fix the quick gaps first

Some gaps close in an afternoon: turning on multi-factor authentication for the last few accounts, taking admin rights away from accounts that don’t need them, disabling accounts for people who have left. Others take weeks, like replacing antivirus with endpoint detection and response, or setting up a backup copy that can’t be deleted.

Start with the ones that turn a no into a yes quickly and cut the most risk. Keep a dated note of what changed, so the answers on the form match a record.

Keep the answers for next year

The same questions come back at the next renewal, and from customers and prime contractors in supplier questionnaires. A short document listing each control, how it’s set up and when it was last checked means next year you’re updating answers instead of finding them again.

Preparing for a cyber insurance renewal goes through the rest of the renewal: who verifies each answer, how to describe work in progress and what to ask your broker about the cover.

If you have a questionnaire in front of you now, the cybersecurity page describes how we help work through one.


Featured Image Credit